As well as featuring Jessica Lange as a new character, the second season of American Horror Story will see a large role for Star Trek star Zachary Quinto.

He will be joined by fellow season one cast members Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson and Lily Rabe, with “everyone… playing the opposite of what they played before,” according to executive producer Ryan Murphy. According to a report at Deadline, Quinto will play one of two male leads and the nemesis to Lange’s character.

American Horror Story starts filming its sophomore year in July.